New York is, without a doubt, the most exciting place I’ve ever lived. Walking these busy sidewalks, one never knows what they will find. Argument between a bum and his army of pigeons? Check. Sidewalk-blanketing class field trip (with no apparent agenda or chaperone) containing what seems to be every middle and high school student from New Jersey? Check. Subway-riding vagrant wiping his own ass with a bare palm while a horrified flock of Meatpacking-bound broker douchebags and their crazy-eyed fashionista arm candy watch? A gut-wrenching check. Needless to say, if you are looking to find it, New York’s got it. And something has to be said for a place that offers so much, right?
Unfortunately, in a place where subtlety is as alien as shame in a nudist colony, the cons seem to greatly outweigh the pros. You can’t go an inch in this city without being physically, spiritually, or emotionally hammered down. Some say that’s what makes the tough as nails New Yorkers “New Yorkers,” but I say it’s bullshit and the reason there are so many unsavory, borderline institution-ready people here. It was with this realization that I decided to leave New York. Below, I have listed the top 10 things I will miss when I shelf this island along with the 10 biggest inspirations for my escape.
==
To Love
10. Good Pizza – Saying pizza is a New York institution is like saying the French are rude. But clichés aside, New York pizza is usually quite good. I say usually because it takes some digging to find the inherently “local” shops. Avoiding anything with the words “famous” or “original” is usually a good idea, as is passing up the place with the audacity to charge more than $5 a slice. As a rule of thumb: if a Manhattanite is willing to cross a river to get to pizza, it’s probably worthwhile.
Nevertheless, I will miss New York pizza and its paper plate destroying, napkin soaking, acne inducing glory. Sure, Chicago-style deep dish is fantastic, but that’s kind of like saying McDonald’s apple pies are just as good as home baked.
9. An Abundant Job Market – Though a locus for film, TV, journalism, publishing, and fashion, just about every job imaginable can be found in New York. Suffice it to say, my aspirations of becoming a beet farmer in Manhattan were quickly squashed, but give it time and those dreams may someday become a reality. Of course, the work culture here is a double-edged sword, so read below to see why New York’s job market isn’t the greatest of pros.
8. A Series of Villages – Though I’m not sure who said it first, whoever first described New York as a “series of villages” was right on the money. Broken up into distinct neighborhoods, New York has a different flavor to offer with each passing block. If vintage (also known as someone else’s stuff), low-fi music, and trucker hats adorned with ironic and obscure phrases are your passion, Williamsburg is the place for you. If your reason for living is strollers, Starbucks, and talking Diaper Genies, you’ve probably already found Park Slope. And if big hair, gold chains, and one-size-too-small tube tops give you that joie de vivre, I’d recommend Staten Island (New Jersey is also a suitable supplement).
With each neighborhood so different from the rest, New York always has something to offer if you know what it is you’re looking for. It’s a fantastic feature for someone susceptible to bouts of pattern boredom or for someone who knows who they are and expects everyone around them to act accordingly. Just don’t go too crazy with your sense of locality, or you might turn into one of “those people” and never leave your neighborhood.
7. Quiet Moments – In a city so omnipresent, it’s easy to forget how wonderful moments of tranquility can be. I used to take silence for granted when I wallowed in the suburbs, but now, faced with a constant barrage of honks, whistles, and yelps, I have learned to not only value, but seek out Zen moments. I can’t meditate, but damn if I don’t appreciate a good sound-proof seal. I will surely live in quieter places and I will surely revert back to taking silence for granted, but if anything, New York taught me to be thankful for what is assumed to be an inherent human right.
6. Inevitable and Socially-Accepted Voyeurism – In a world before TV, while the rest of the country was probably reading books or whittling wood, New Yorkers were looking out their windows, watching their neighbors and playing out fantasy storylines in their diversion-starved brains. This was the setting for Hitchcock’s Rear Window, and it’s as true as it’s ever been (probably since silent people watching actually is more enticing than digesting this week’s editions of “twenty former strippers vie for the attention of a forgotten B-celeb” or “the right-wing Christian conservative and hedonistic bisexual inner-city twentysomething roommates have an argument.”
“People watching” (as we’ll call it so as not to alert the attentions of the local authorities) is not only a great way to fight boredom while inspiring one’s imagination, but is something I realize I won’t be able to do forever. I’m sure the bulb planting exploits of future neighbors “Herb and Josie” across the white picket fence will pale in comparison with the tireless worker across the street, who, upon his fourth “working Sunday” in a row, gives me just cause to believe he is addicted to internet porn, has forgotten the name of his first-born son, and is having an interracial, extra-marital affair with his office’s Bolivian cleaning lady. Who needs suburban chit-chat and reality shows when I’ve got front-row tickets to my own personal “reality show?”
5. 24-Hour Convenience – This is probably one of New York’s biggest claims to fame. Need a falafel at 3:45 AM? You got it! The city that never sleeps really doesn’t, and all your off-hour hankerings will reap the benefits. One caveat: many of the “big box” stores follow their corporate-mandated hours pretty rigidly. I guess they should have called it “the city whose bars, restaurants, and pharmacies never sleep.”
4. The Arts – Broadway. The Met. Carnegie Hall. Lincoln Center. ‘Nuff said.
3. No Need for a Car – This was one of the biggest factors drawing me into New York’s concrete bosom. Sure, cruising with the windows down on a sunny Sunday afternoon had become one of my favorite ways to escape in college. But with gas prices rising like an Alabama thermometer in July, commuting times from the suburbs rounding over an hour, and every other one of the million annoyances with owning a car constantly nipping at my heels, it sounded like a real deal to shed myself of my old bucket of bolts. More on this later, though…
2. Cupcakes – I’ve blogged about this before, so I’ll spare the diatribe again. Suffice it to say, I have never before nor will I ever again experience a nugget of joy quite like Sugar Sweet Sunshine’s cupcakes. They are a reason in and of themselves to take a 45-minute subway ride downtown and are nothing I could ever recreate on my own (believe me, I’ve tried). SSS has set the bar high, and I’m sure with each new cupcakery I hesitantly enter, I will think back to that sweet little nook down on Rivington (sue me, I’m a sap for the cakes).
1. “The Story” – When you have lived in New York, everyone wants a little taste of your experience there. You know they secretly want to know how much you hated it (and who could blame them, as everything they’ve come to value about the suburbs is regularly effigied and burned in our parks and squares), but they typically smile and nod as you recount the good times had at this bar or on that avenue.
The good news is, people’s passing interest in what life is really like in New York is your prime opportunity to vent and blow the clichés and stereotypes about New York wide open. No, not everyone does coke (though one trip to Meatpacking on a Saturday night might sway your opinion otherwise). No, we don’t all sit in coffee shops all day every day (especially when it’s nowhere near where we work) to mull over the minutia of our lives and use phrases like “yadda, yadda, yadda.” And no, we really don’t know our neighbors and hang out with them regularly. New York is not what it seems to be on the big and little screens.
As you find yourself rifling through the various things that are often “blindspotted” in the media’s depiction of New York (effectively shattering your audience’s desire to ever visit your old stomping ground), you may find yourself listing some of the following:
To Leave
10. Short-Sighted Locals – There are three types of people in New York: tourists, 1-2 year temporaries, and true “New Yawkahs.” The last set is comprised of those who sport a year-round shine of under-sunned skin, mutter angrily to themselves when map-toting tourists call the Chrystler Building the Empire State Building, and are convinced everything outside the 212 area code is bucktoothed, gun-toting, cousin-loving farmland. These are people who are proud they’ve never left their county and think that enraptured discussions of how to get from point A to point B constitute “conversation.” It could be easy to side with these individuals, since they’ve grown up within a self-serving microcosm. Why go out for burgers when you’ve got steak at home, right?
The problem is that New Yorkers (by birthright or years logged) are often unable to give good reason as to what makes New York better than everywhere else. “You can find anything you would ever want!” Okay, maybe a good argument for a sadomasochist with a penchant for grilled zebra steaks and all-night coke bars. But what about us “normies” out there? In all honesty, New York doesn’t offer anything you can’t find anywhere else; it simply has more of it to offer. It would seem New Yorkers, veiled in net of ill-inspired faux pride, have just been drinking the tap water for too long.
Plus, how can you respect a 45-year-old who still doesn’t know how to drive?
9. Transplant Divas – If HBO had one effect on New York, it was filling the city’s streets with millions of hopeful young Carrie Bradshaw doppelgangers. SoHo has become nearly uninhabitable while you can’t walk up 5th Ave. without making way for a Burberry-draped flock of girls shoulder-to-shoulder and 10 across. These are girls in their big sunglasses with toy dog-stuffed designer knockoffs who say things like “cabs are the only way I get around here.” The thing is, (unbeknownst to them) their lives here are a temporary fantasy and they’ll be gone after witnessing their first bum masturbating into a finely-trimmed Park Avenue hedge. Of course, with a certain movie’s release on the horizon, it’s only a matter of time before another army of mini divas march these sidewalks.
8. Too Many Chutes and Not Enough Ladders – As mentioned above, just about every job can be had in New York. The problem is, for every available position, there are about 4000 backstabbing, throat-stomping workforce zombies clamoring for a new gig. This unbalanced supply and demand has led to a corporate climate of ladder climbers and lifelong “yes” men. Like a fraternity, the work world in New York is based on a system of paying your dues. You start at the bottom, getting coffee and making Outlook appointments until someone quits or dies. On this blessed day (yes, New York will make you hope for these typically unsavory events), you get to move up a peg toward the position of your dreams.
The problem is you’re still decades away from achieving the position you really want (and, frankly, deserve). With this realization, one of two things will happen: 1) you throw it into cruise control and glide your way through a lackluster life of mediocrity, or 2) you quit and begin the backstabbing and throat stomping all over again. It’s a never-ending cycle and it brings out the worst in people. Though some competition makes people strive to improve, too much competition makes people New Yorkers.
7. “I’d Rather Serve Myself, Thank You” – In New York, you’re always relying on others: the conductor of the subway you take to work; the concierge in your building; the fry jockey at your local McDonald’s. The problem with relying on others (and this is anywhere; not specifically New York) is that people are usually quite unreliable. There’s a reason the old adage, “if you want something done right you gotta do it yourself,” has stood true for so long.
In New York, this problem (like so many others) is magnified almost cartoonishly. Cashiers often talk on their cell phones while ringing up customers. Restaurant servers will regularly blunder their orders. And biggest of all, customers are typically met with attitude when demanding good service. Recently, while attempting to correct a problem with my cable service (after waiting on hold for 25 minutes, no less), I was interrupted by the person on the other end because, apparently, listening to my story of how the problem came to be was too much for the phone rep to bear.
People here have lost the ability to effectively communicate. What should be a normal conversation regularly turns to an argument because New Yorkers are “much too busy” to listen. To burst through their mirrored boxes and get anything done properly, I’ll have to send a text message next time.
6. Lackluster Cuisine – Through some divine intervention, New York got a reputation for having some of the country’s best food. As a side note, I will say I do not regularly dine at four- and five-star restaurants. Somehow, I simply cannot justify $65 for an overcooked chicken wing draped with damp, floppy foliage. I guess I’m not a “foodie.”
But self-declarations aside, if you’re not eating within the top tier, the food in New York just plain sucks. Plates are small and costly; items typically served complementary (like chips and salsa at a freaking Mexican restaurant) are an added expense on the bill; and most of the time, even with minimal culinary training, you could certainly make the dishes at home. Only twice have I eaten out and thought it wasn’t something I could have made myself (both of which were on my company and involved cuts of meat not typically found floating in soup kitchen cauldrons).
I eat out more than I’d like, but only because my kitchen is so damn uninspiring and uninviting. More on that later, though…
5. The Waiting Game – For a fast-paced city, things move very slowly in New York. I regularly spend 45 minutes in line at Whole Foods, buckling under the weight of my produce as my apples stare up at me as if to say, “Are we really worth this?” I would write more, but I have to go spend an hour underground for two miles of travel.
4. No Privacy – For those worried about what other people think, the only advice I can offer is do not move to New York. You are never alone, and someone is always watching (remember number 6 from the Pros). If you can curb your need to sing along with your iPod or engage in rough monkey sex in your paper-thin walled apartment, this shouldn’t be a problem. Unfortunately, this apparently isn’t always possible for some people which leads us to the number 3 reason New York sucks…
3. No Sense of Public Shame – Between the bums pooping into public garbage cans, the Harlem hooligans blasting their boomboxes at a crowd of tired, stressed subway rush hour commuters, and the sparring couples airing each others’ infidelities and shortcomings out on the sidewalk, New York seems to be a place where people don’t mind bearing their ugly souls. I guess it’s a good thing people don’t feel censored here. But Jesus, it doesn’t leave me feeling good about the state of humanity!
2. “The City’s a Toilet” – The aforementioned is a brilliant quote from one of Elaine Benes’s JAP-y Long Island friends on Seinfeld, and God is it true. Between the teenager-high mountains of garbage, sidewalk minefields of dog crap, and an ever-lingering potpourri of what can only be human refuse and week-old tuna, New York isn’t exactly the sterile steel and glass playground it appears to be on TV and in movies. I’d recommend a trip down to Chinatown on a steamy July day to understand what I’m talking about. Let’s just say, if there were no New York, there’d be no Purell.
1. An Ever-Shrinking Bank Account – New York is expensive. Oh, and the sky is blue, and humans need air to live, and cheese is disgusting, and… Oops, sorry; I got caught on an assembly line of truths there. Anyway, yes, it’s no lie that New York will feed off of your bank account like a hacker in some lame 80’s caper.
The thing is, everything costs money here. To get anywhere on a rotting, antiquated transit system, you are blitzkrieged into paying. Eating out is less a special event and more a self-induced stress fest when the check arrives. And for tiny, vapid, shitbox apartments probably not much bigger than the slave quarters of 19th century Alabama, we New Yorkers pay what could have covered an owner’s fee for some nice townhouse in any other city (save for, maybe, Boston and San Francisco).
New York is, by all means, a rich person’s playground. Sure, Average Joes can survive (look at me), but it’s a meager lifestyle. But with limited space, an ever-growing skyline of tenements-turned-luxury high rises, and a constant influx of rich celebs and their oddly-named babies, New York will price out the middle class and will become the most decrepit gated community in the country. When that happens, I’ll be happy my only interaction with New York is seeing it flash as my weekly sitcoms change scenes.
==
So there you have it: New York in a nutshell. Of course, I’m sure I missed some features (and really, what Top-10 list is ever complete?), so feel free to add thoughts in the comments.
For those who think I’m leaving New York a defeated man, I can only say I am not. There’s an old adage about New York that goes, “If you can make it here, you can make it anywhere.” I’m sure this is true, as the cost and hassle of any place else will pale in comparison. But even if I discover my next home’s shortcomings and restart my “grass is greener” thinking patterns, I can take solace in knowing that no place is perfect and you’ve got to work to find what makes you happy. New York taught me that.